The Good Phight: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





MLB Band List, Part II - American League

Following up on last week's story, here's Part II of the MLB Band List:

(Also, go check out the baseball/band videos at Fanhouse TV for a different take on the whole affair...)

American League

AL East

Baltimore Orioles are The Doors: Best known for their work in the 60s and 70s, they experienced a brief resurgence in the 90s thanks to a wealthy, powerful control freak (Peter Angelos; Oliver Stone). Featured a number of talented performers, but overwhelmingly identified with possibly the least talented one (Cal Ripken, Jr.; Jim Morrison). Countless American twenty-somethings are left with tons of related paraphernalia purchased in their teen years when it was "cool" to like them. Depend on nostalgia (Camden Yards) to keep fans coming back.

Boston Red Sox are U2: Strong Irish cultural identification. Began as plucky, spirited upstarts who strongly advocated for (and were advocated by) the oppressed, eventually became the 800 pound gorilla of the sport/industry. Incredibly wealthy, spending tons of money to perform for fans, but creating high-grade psychic dissonance vis-à-vis their past and present advocacy for the poor. Resented for their popularity and perceived pretentiousness, especially by those who were fans "before they got famous." Ridiculous hair.

New York Yankees are Led Zeppelin: Loved and hated in nearly equal measure. Bombastic cultural touchstone, definitive in the genre despite a sizeable portion of their work being appropriated from other sources (Kansas City A’s / free agency; Robert Johnson / J.R.R. Tolkien). Wore the same clothing for decades. Personality clashes defined and seemingly enhanced the quality of their performance. Much of their cachet derived from metaphysical sources (the occult; "mystique and aura").

Tampa Bay Rays are New Kids on the Block: Young kids thrown together to perform, we’ve watched them for years and seen them age without ever seeming to improve in any cognizable way. Latter-era name change (Rays; NKOTB) seen as desperate attempt to confer legitimacy on the whole sad enterprise.

Toronto Blue Jays are Rush: Canadian. Fully distinct from their pastoral origins, they engage in a sterile, technically exacting exhibition greatly appreciated by a few, almost completely ignored by most. Talents of individual members (Neal Peart; Vernon Wells) ceaselessly touted by enthusiasts, but the group as a whole sputters. 

AL Central

Chicago White Sox are Warren Zevon: With a smaller, devoted fan-base, toiled for years in relative obscurity compared to their contemporaries (Cubs; Jackson Browne). Sordid pasts (Black Sox; drugs). Briefly moved to the forefront of cultural landscape with 1980s sports films (Field of Dreams / Eight Men Out; The Color of Money). Ultimately had the last laugh (2005 World Series; The Wind).

Cleveland Indians are Parliament-Funkadelic: Despite a rotating cast of players, they maintain an unusually high level of performance for a relatively un-moneyed organization. While they likely won’t recapture their glory years, they should remain really good for the time being. Represented by cartoon(ish) front men (Chief Wahoo; George Clinton / Bootsy Collins).

Detroit Tigers are Johnny Cash: Industry mainstays who were brought back from the brink by a cult figure with entertaining facial hair (Jim Leyland; Rick Rubin) who conferred instant credibility on a once down-and-out entity. An often dark past (Ty Cobb, Denny McLain / drug abuse) combined with a close alignment with religious individuals (Tom Monaghan; June Carter Cash).

Kansas City Royals are Pat Boone: Peaked decades ago and now largely irrelevant. Succeeded in the past in large part by exploiting the work of talented African-Americans. Brief surge in 1990s didn’t really fool anyone (the heavy metal album; signing David Cone). Now only really enjoyed by people in small pockets of Missouri (Branson; K.C. metro area).

Minnesota Twins are Prince: The Minnesota association is obvious. Both enterprises run by wealthy eccentrics whose relations with others in the industry are strained at best. Greatest period of success in the mid 80s through early 90s. Gigantic, idiosyncratic home base (Metrodome; Paisley Park).

AL West

Los Angeles Angels are Jefferson Airplane / Starship: Frequent, senseless, and largely mocked name changes. Originated in 1960s California. Impressive groups of talent overshadowed by years of shocking collapses and sadness (1986 ALCS, September 1995; break-ups, relationship disasters, deaths). Latter-era surge in success attributed to silly things (Rally Monkeys; the Mannequin soundtrack).

Oakland A’s are The Velvet Underground: Pretty much unimpeachably cool to be a fan. Hero worship and derision of the group mastermind are rampant in almost equal measure (Andy Warhol; Billy Beane). They have served as inspiration for countless imitators, even if their own commercial success largely eluded them.

Seattle Mariners are The Yardbirds: Numerous members went on to greater success and fame elsewhere (Alex Rodriguez, Randy Johnson / Jeff Beck, Jimmy Page, Eric Clapton) despite being extremely talented and accomplished in their own right. The sum was less than the whole of the parts as applied to record sales / postseason victories; it’s hard to comprehend, years later, how those original lineups failed to become the BIGGEST THING EVER in light of the talent on hand.

Texas Rangers are The Commodores: Accomplished if not outstanding for a number of years, began to suffer as a functioning unit when a milquetoast frontman took over (you know who… for both). Said frontman proceeded to leave the group and prove, despite great personal and commercial success, that he’s a lame-o and nobody likes him. The original group has yet to recover from its draining and fleeting but profound association with that turd.

0 recs | Comment 6 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Cal Ripken Jr possibly the least talented one?

He certainly was a tale of 2 careers, but the first half was pretty darn remarkable for a SS.

Career 112 OPS+.

First 10 years: OPS+ off over 100 every year.
Last 10 years: OPS+ of over 100 3 times.

That may be due to the huge power spike, but an interesting dichotomy.

by jonk on Apr 1, 2008 11:43 PM EDT   0 recs

Jonk, I did an analysis of Ripken at the end of October '07 if you're interested. I arrived at the same conclusion you did.

WholeCamels, great list, can't really argue with any of them.

http://crashburnalley.com/

by Crashburn Alley on Apr 1, 2008 11:54 PM EDT   0 recs

I might have compared the Twins (of this decade) to the Replacements: critically acclaimed, always seemingly on the verge of breaking through, never quite getting there, and then finally the front man throws his arms up and leaves in hopes of finding wealth and glory somewhere else.

And I'm not sure Genesis wouldn't be a better comp for the Orioles: glorious once upon a time, but eventually it just got embarrassing to the point where you ask yourself why they just don't freakin' give it up. Then you remember: it's the money.

But otherwise... tremendous. This group, especially the Yankees and Red Sox, might be even more spot-on than the NL group.

by dajafi on Apr 2, 2008 12:02 AM EDT   0 recs

The best part of that analogy is that said front man never did find that glory.

by taco pal on Apr 2, 2008 12:25 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

excellent

again, great post.

The bit on the Cleveland Indians made me reflect on just how terribly racist chief wahoo is. Putting aside for a moment that the name "Indians" is problematic in its own right, what we have is essentially a samboized portrayal of a Native American man (complete with red skin and feather) - clearly a remnant of Jim Crow era racial ideology (chief wahoo was born in 1946). That this terrible image can still be the emblem of a franchise, let alone the public face of a multi-million dollar business is deeply disturbing. As my political science professor Adolph Reed has said jokingly, they might as well be called the "Cleveland grinning coons."

sorry that this is off topic, but it really bothers me.

by FuquaManuel on Apr 2, 2008 12:05 AM EDT   0 recs

I'm with ya

The kicker is that the Indians have been my favorite AL team since my first trip to Jacobs Field in May 1994, for second-row seats at a game won by Albert Belle with an extra-inning walkoff bomb. I love pretty much everything about the Tribe, except that hideous logo. They can't retire it soon enough, and I'm always at a loss as to why they haven't come under more pressure to do that.

by dajafi on Apr 2, 2008 12:55 AM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Analysis and features focusing on Philadelphia Phillies baseball.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Ray_charles_small
Jayson Werth
Small
Chad Durbin blogs about his all star break
Small
First-Place Falls
Super_grover_small
So the Phillies are looking at Blanton... interesting
Meltingface_small
Marson, Donald Will Play for USA
Meltingface_small
Trade Target: A.J. Burnett
Small
So... I'm just going to say it
Phillyfriar_small
Discussion point: Bedard or Burnett?
Small
NL All-Stars
Boys_small
Best active players never an All-Star by OPS+

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

Next Game

Philadelphia Phillies Red-star
@ Florida Marlins Red-star

Sunday, Jul 20, 2008, 1:10 PM EDT
Dolphin Stadium

Cole Hamels vs Josh Johnson

Partly cloudy. Winds blowing out to left field at 10-15 m.p.h. Game Time temperature: Around 85.

Complete Coverage >


Site Meter