Who Gets the Call?
With just a week left in the minor-league season, the Phillies’ clubhouse is about to get a little more crowded. Rosters expand to 40 men on September 1, and the Phils—with a short bench and at-times overworked bullpen—figure to utilize some relief. So who might we see for the last month of the season?
As he so often does, assistant GM Mike Arbuckle poured some cold water on fans’ hopes of seeing some of the organization’s more highly touted prospects. Shortstop Jason Donald and catcher Lou Marson, stars of the U.S. bronze medal-winning baseball team, are heading back to Reading from Beijing for now, and they’re unlikely to continue on to Philadelphia before the end of the season. About the best Arbuckle offers is that "both guys are making significant progress and have [earned]… consideration to be here at some point next year." The most prominent Reading teammate they left behind, outfielder Greg Golson, probably isn’t coming either.
(But that's okay; who could argue that there's any need for improvement on the part of the Phils' catchers, backup SS Eric Bruntlett, or pinch-hitter/pinch-runner/defensive replacement extraordinaire So Taguchi?)
Thus, probably nobody from Reading… well, unless you count this guy, who might get a recall but is pretty much certain not to appear in anything resembling a key situation. To be fair, his ERA in double-A is more than two runs lower than what he did in low-A…
How about the Phillies’ other last-place entrant in the high minors, the Lehigh Valley IronPigs? Already, current Pigs pitchers J.A. Happ, R.J. Swindle, Les Walrond and (though he didn’t get into a game) Joe Bisenius, as well as hitters Mike Cervenak, Chris Snelling and T.J. Bohn, have passed through. On the pitching side, there’s also Kris Benson, the rehabbing pitcher the club signed rather than Kyle Lohse; Carlos Carrasco, who pitched another gem Sunday night and has a 2.10 ERA with 37 strikeouts in 30 triple-A innings; Fabio Castro, the undersized lefty who worked out of the Phillies bullpen in stints during the 2006 and 2007 seasons; and Travis Blackley, the former Rule 5 selection who competed for a rotation spot last spring.
Of the pitchers, my guess is that Benson gets recalled as something of a courtesy, as well as Happ and one of the three other lefties: Castro, Swindle and Walrond. My preference would be Castro, who has the best stuff and has enjoyed some success in the majors. Carrasco might have pitched himself into consideration for a rotation job next spring, but the team might feel that 150 innings—the total he’ll likely crack after his last Lehigh Valley start next weekend—is enough for this 21 year-old arm. They could use him out of the bullpen in September, but that’s an unaccustomed role for Carrasco with more risk than reward. Happ, Castro and Swindle are already on the 40-man roster; Benson, Walrond and Carrasco are not. But the Phils have four pitchers--Tom Gordon, Scott Mathieson, Francisco Rosario and Mike Zagurski--who can be moved from the 15-day to the 60-day disabled list, freeing up spots.
On the positional side, Snelling likely will come back—if he can stay healthy between now and Sept. 1, anyway—and it would be a big surprise if the Phillies didn’t recall catcher Jason Jaramillo simply to give Charlie Manuel more late-game options. With Andy Tracy already on the active roster, the odds for Cervenak or Bohn getting the call might be lower; more useful would be one or both of Rich Thompson and Brandon Watson, slap-hitting outfielders who would have represented an upgrade on Taguchi two months ago. Thompson has 25 steals in 27 attempts and a walk rate near 10 percent; Watson has a higher batting average and played in the majors for Washington last year, and at age 26 he’s faintly more prospect-like. Only Jaramillo is on the 40-man right now, but in addition to the flexibility gained by moving Zagurski et al to the 60-day, there's considerable dead weight that could be cut loose: Oscar Robles, Cervenak, even Taguchi.
My prediction is that Benson, Happ, Castro and Eaton are recalled to bolster the pitching staff, and that Jaramillo, Snelling, and Watson take spots at the end of the Phillies’ bench. My preference would be to see those same three pitchers from Lehigh Valley, and Jaramillo, Snelling, Donald, Marson and Golson on the positional side. Here’s hoping there’s at least one Marty Bystrom 1980 or Len Matuszek 1983 in the bunch.
0 recs |
6 comments
Comments
That’s a good take on things, dajafi, and thanks for addressing this issue. I was wondering when someone would start the speculation on this front.
Pretty much agreed with your take. But here’s a question: with the rosters expanding, the team is allowed to use anyone on the 40-man, correct? Assuming that’s right, I’d transfer Zagurski, Mathieson, and Gordon to the 60-day DL, and I’d honestly consider DFA-ing Bohn and Robles if I needed more room. Then you can pretty much go hog wild, since you have 15 spots to play with.
For the pitching, agreed on Benson, Happ, Castro and Eaton (though reluctantly on the latter). Swindle could be used solely against lefties — though I know he struggled his first time up — and Matt Childers could make the 40-man if there’s room, since he’s been very good for Lehigh Valley. For the position players, agreed on Jaramillo, Snelling, Donald, Marson, and Golson (the latter 2 have to be placed on the 40-man for next year anyway).
That’s 5 men — Donald, Marson, Golson, Snelling, and Childers — to add to the 40-man, but it can be done. And it’d make me feel a helluva lot better if we need a pinch runner late in games and we can call on Golson instead of Kyle Kendrick again.
by PhillyFriar on Aug 25, 2008 5:02 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
While I’m not necessarily saying I’d object, I have no particular desire to see Donald, Marson, Carrasco, or Golson brought up. I have a totally unscientific theory that not giving a younger prospect a September cup of coffee just keeps ’em hungry to improve even more the following season. Otherwise, you run the risk of either making them complacent, or setting them up to be irrationally discouraged when they start the next year back in the minors.
The only guys I’d promote are those who either have some sort of specialized skill that could help the team even in limited action, or who are already penciled in to make the team out of the spring training next year. I guess Golson arguably fits the first category but whatever. Happ definitely fits the second category so I’d like to see him here. I know the other guys have a shot at making the team too, but I don’t think it’s particularly likely. With Happ, I’d give him better than 50/50 odds.
by taco pal on Aug 25, 2008 6:24 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Interesting. I think you might have something there, but the other side of it is how much the young players might learn from being in that pressurized situation, but not finding themselves squarely in the crosshairs.
Though I think he’s probably the least of the three position prospects, I agree that Golson makes the most sense for a recall since he’s faster and a better defender than Taguchi—and maybe he would gain the most from being around someone like Burrell, with his approach to hitting.
by dajafi on Aug 25, 2008 7:39 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
By the way, I heard somewhere that Golson’s plate discipline has improved over the course of the season. Minorleaguesplits seems to confirm this. Limited PAs, of course, but maybe a new reason for cautious optimism.
by taco pal on Aug 25, 2008 7:49 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Call-ups
There are quite a few players who deserve to be called up. Adam Eaton certainly is not one of them. He has over a 7 ERA since being sent down! I think he needs to be released outright to save us from his competing for the 5th rotation spot next spring. IF he is not released the organization will give him every chance to make the rotation next year which will take a spot from one of our good prospects (Happ, Carrasco) or even Kris Benson if we sign him on for another year. We have been paying dead money for other players (Thome, Abreu, Helms). Now that we will have had all of them off the books, it is time to pay Eaton his dead money and move on.
Brandon Watson has had a nice yr at Lehigh and deserves a September spot. He hits for average (even if it is almost all singles). I would rather have him come in as a defensive replacement than So Taguchi. J.A. Happ will certainly be called up for september. Matt Childers has also had a nice year with 20 saves and a sub 3 era despite playing for an awful team. Steve green has also had a nice yr for lehigh. with an ERA around 3 and more than 1 k per inning. Kris Benson will certainly get called up to get some mlb work. I would not be at all surprised to see him up before the 1st to have him eligible for playoffs if necessary. Stephen Randolph needs to be called up. He may be 34 but his strikeuts per inning are sick. 87 ks in 57 innings this yr deserves a spot in bullpen. R.J. Swindle has had a terrific yr in the minors but was shaky in MLB. Carrasco should not be called up unless we need him for the rotation. Lou Marson and Jason Donald are obvious choices to come up but as we know are unlikely to be called up. Greg Golson will certainly get a call up and his play has merited as much. His batting average has steadily increased and his power numbers are not shabby. A guy we never hear of is Neil Sellers. He is a 3b and has had a very nice year.
So my list is:
Pitchers-J.A. Happ, Matt Childers, Steve Green, Kris Benson, Stephen Randolph
Hitters-Brandon Watson, Lou Marson, Jason Donald, Greg Golson, Neil Sellers
by schrifty on Aug 26, 2008 8:55 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Stephen Randolph fascinates me. The strikeouts really are sick. Unfortunately, so are the walks…
I read somewhere else last night that some Reading people think Golson actually will be recalled. The question I think is whether he and Watson might be redundant.
by dajafi on Aug 26, 2008 11:36 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 

















