How do the Phillies measure up with the rest of the National League, position by position? We will look at WAR from Fangraphs for an overall measure, as well as hitting and fielding measures that are its main components. We'll also take a look at OPS by position using the position splits at baseball-reference.com:
Fangraphs: WAR, Hitting (wOBA), and Defense
For each position, Fangraphs counts all the stats of any player who has spent at least one third of their time there, which leads to some double counting. For the Phillies, that means that 1) Galvis (-0.9 WAR and .084 wOBA), Nix (-0.3, .207), and Brignac (-0.1, .000) are all counted at both 3B and SS, and 2) that Tony Gwynn Jr. (-0.4, .251) is counted at both LF and CF.
It usually doesn't make a big difference except in cases like those of Colorado's Charlie Blackmon, who has split time between Center and Left, and so all of his stats get counted at both.
Without further ado, how the Phils look by position:
C: Phils catchers rank near the top in wOBA, and are solidly above average in combined fWAR. Defensively however they are surprisingly low, with the 3rd lowest runs vs. average in the NL.
1B: When the defense ranks a little better than the hitting, you know the hitting isn't where it needs to be.
2B: Highest in the NL in both wOBA and WAR. Utley's defense is about average, but the total is brought down by Nix's -0.6.
3B: If only Asche's stats counted here, wOBA would be second best in the NL, behind only Washington (although WAR would still be near the bottom). Defensively, thanks in large part to Asche's -7.4, the -8.6 runs at the position is one of the worst by any team at any one spot.
SS: Similar to 3B, if only Rollins counted here, the Phils would have the 2nd highest WAR, and 3rd highest wOBA.
OF: Between LF and CF, the most impressive number so far has been, surprisingly, Dom Brown's defense. Marlon Byrd has been unspectacular but solid both offensively and defensively in RF.