With 112 games in the books, Ryan Howard is hitting a measly .215/.297/.366, for a .293 wOBA and 84 wRC+. Including his subpar fielding and baserunning, fWAR is below replacement level, at -0.5. Out of 23 qualifying first basemen, the only one with worse numbers this year is Nick Swisher (.280 wOBA, 77 wRC+, -1.5 fWAR).
In spite of that, Howard has managed to drive in 63 runs, good for 7th most in the National League (and tied with Marlon Byrd for the Phillies team lead).
Assuming he gets similar playing time in the balance of the season, Howard is on pace for 91 RBI by the end of the year. That doesn't quite have the ring or cachet as the nice round 100 RBI number, but 90 RBIs would have been an impressive amount for much of baseball history. Tony Perez, for example, is famous for, among other things, driving in 90 runs or more for 11 straight seasons.
Dr. Ryan Jekyll/Mr. Ryan Hyde
After getting off to a respectable and encouraging start, Howard has really struggled in the 80 games since May 1st: .203/.286/.333 (.615 OPS). And yet, somehow, he has managed to drive in 49 runs in those 80, a pace of 99 over a full season of 162 games.
How is this possible? Chase Utley, Jimmy Rollins, and Ben Revere have combined for an ok but not great .325 OBP over that time. But as has been the case for much of his career, Howard has hit better with runners in scoring position, largely because opponents don't employ a defensive shift in those situations:
Since May 1st with RISP (112 PA): .211/.321/.432 (.753 OPS)
Since May 1st, all other (231 PA): .199/.268/.289 (.557 OPS) -- oof!
His splits for the full season to date are similar, although his non-RISP numbers are somewhat better thanks to his decent start:
with RISP (149 PA): .208/.322/.432 (.754 OPS)
all other (301 PA): .222/.289/.342 (.631 OPS)
So he has come through in some key situations, although obviously even that .754 OPS is still below par for a first baseman.
But then all those other PAs count too, and as currently projected, Howard's overall final 2014 stats would be among the worst ever for players with 90+ RBIs, whether we measure by wOBA, wRC+, or overall WAR.
There have been 2,722 player seasons with 90 or more RBIs since 1900. The few listed below are the worst of the worst, the pinnacle of driving in a lot of runs, while hurting your team on the field in virtually every other aspect of the game:
1) by wOBA
In terms of overall hitting, measured by the comprehensive wOBA, Howard's season is on track to be the 3rd worst in history by any player with 90+ RBIs.
The "honor" of the worst goes to third baseman Tony Batista who drove in 99 runs for the 2003 Orioles in spite of hitting only .235/.270/.393. He followed that up with a similar though not quite as bad season in the Expos' last season in Montreal (9th on the list).
2) by wRC+
When adjusting wOBA for the player's league and park to get wRC+, Batista's 2003 is still the worst 90 RBI season ever, with Howard' 2014 projection coming in in a tie for 12th.
Note that old friend Pedro Feliz is high on the list, with the season that (presumably) was key in the Phillies deciding to sign him as a free agent two years later.
3) by fWAR
Based on the players' total contributions in a season, as measured by fWAR, Howard is projected to finish with the 10th worst season in history overall by a player with 90 or more RBIs.
Tony Batista's relatively less disastrous -0.1 fWAR in 2003 doesn't make the cut in this view. Instead, leading the way is Ruben Sierra, who combined very bad hitting with -25.0 UZR, his worst of many horrible fielding seasons.
Dante Bichette's 1999 at #2 is a special case. Not only did he have 133 RBIs, by far the most of any season on these lists, but his .298/.354/.541 line is actually very good. However playing in the extreme environment of Coors Field reduces his wRC+ to only league average. But the icing on this cake is the 34 runs below average that Total Zone assigns him in the outfield. He was always a terrible fielder, but never rated as bad as he did that season.
Other perhaps surprising names on this list:
- Joe Carter, who still haunts many Phillies fans, appears on the list three times. Cold comfort.
- Wiz Kid left fielder Del Ennis in 1956, his worst (and last) year with the Phillies
- All-time great Ken Griffey Jr. near the end of his career, still hitting well, but a shadow of his former self in the field, rated as 29.1 runs below average
- Former two-time MVP Dave Parker, also near the end, combining a down season at the plate with his usual terrible fielding
Ryan Howard has come through many times this season and helped the Phillies win some games. However with his complete and utter disappearance when there aren't runners in scoring position (in most cases meaning that the shift is on), it's looking like this will be one of the worst seasons ever by a hitter who manages to drive in a lot of runs.