clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What is the awesomest Cliff Lee has ever awesomed?

With Lee's retirement, here's a look at his 12 greatest games, according to Baseball Reference.

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Cliff Lee is apparently retiring, as noted by our own Eric Chesterton wrote about on the website Tuesday morning.

This is sad, but not unexpected. After all, Lee has missed most of the last two seasons and, although he was considering a comeback this off-season, it appears as if that isn't going to happen.

So I thought I'd re-post part of a piece I did back in 2014, chronicling the 12 best games Cliff Lee ever pitched. Here it is below. Enjoy!


Happily, the good folks at Baseball Reference have a way of figuring this out for us. Using Game Score, which starts at 50 points and gives additional points for innings completed after the 4th, strikeouts, and outs recorded, and takes points away for walks and hits given up, as well as both earned and unearned runs, we can tally the very best performances of Cliff's career.

So, according to that metric, here are Cliff Lee's 12 Greatest Games, because a Top 10 is for losers and saps and people who don't REALLY care that much about Cliff Lee. (click on the link for video... embed is being screwy)

#12: September 15, 2011 - Phils 2 Marlins 1

Lee pitched nine innings against the Marlins, however, was not credited with the win thanks to an inept Phils' offense. Instead, the victory went to the indomitable Michael Schwimmer, who pitched the 10th, then watched as the Phils scored the game-winner in the bottom of the inning on a walk-off Ryan Howard double. Lee, however, was brilliant, giving up 5 hits in 9 innings and one earned run, with 12 strikeouts and 0 walks, giving him a Game Score of 85.

#11: April 18, 2012 - Giants 1 Phillies 0

This was one of two games the Phillies lost among Lee's 10 best, and this one really hurt. Lee went 10 innings and gave up nothing. Just 7 hits, 7 strikeouts and no walks, good enough for a Game Score of 85. However, San Francisco won it in the bottom of the 11th off Antonio Bastardo on a single by Melky Cabrera.

I hate the Giants.

#10: September 27, 2013 - Braves 1 Phillies 0

This time, Lee took the "L" himself, yet pitched an eight inning complete game as the Phils were unable to score against Atlanta. In those 8 innings, Lee gave up just 3 hits and 1 earned run, struck out 13 and walked nobody, good enough, again, for a Game Score of 85.

In case you're counting, that's two runs for the Phillies in these three Cliff Lee games, two of which the team lost. Don't worry, though. Things get better.

#9: Game 3, 2009 NLCS - Phillies 11 Dodgers 0

One of the most enjoyable playoff games in Phillies history was also one of the most dominant performances of Lee's career. He pitched eight innings and gave up just three hits with 10 strikeouts and 0 walks. He also got a bit of help from the offense that night, which precluded him from finishing the game himself, otherwise this performance would be ranked higher.

#8: April 21, 2014 - Phillies 7 Dodgers 0

Yes, that's right. Last night's game was among the 10 best games Cliff Lee has ever pitched in his career. His Game Score of 86 ties him with the next two games on this list. You really did see one of the best games Lee has ever pitched last night in Los Angeles.

#7: June 28, 2011 - Phillies 5 Red Sox 0

Lee pitched a complete game shutout against the Sox, giving up just two hits and two walks, but only struck out five in this one. Lee was in the midst of one of his patented unhittable runs of dominance, his third straight complete game victory.

#6: May 4, 2013 - Phillies 2 Braves 0

Lee went eight innings in this one, holding the Braves to just two hits and no runs with 8 strikeouts and no walks. These are starting to become old hat now.

#5: July 27, 2010 - Rangers 3 A's 1

We don't like to think about a time when Cliff Lee did not pitch for the Phillies, but a time did exist when he played for others we dare not speak of. Except the Mariners. We can remember, and giggle, as we remember he once pitched for the Mariners.

As a Ranger, he pitched a complete game shutout against Oakland in which he gave up one run (not earned) on five hits with 13 strikeouts and no walks. Those high-strikeout/no walk performances are a staple to get on this list, giving him a Game Score of 88.

#4: April 24, 2008 - Indians 2 Royals 0

It's hard to remember that Lee actually won a Cy Young Award the same season the Phillies won the World Series, only he didn't win it for them. He won it for Cleveland. Yuck.

Anyway, Lee pitched a complete game, nine-inning shutout, giving up just three hits, striking out 9 without a walk, good enough for a Game Score of 90 in this one.

#3: October 18, 2010 - Rangers 8 Yankees 0

In the 2010 ALCS, Lee dominated the Yankees, much like he had the year before for the Phils in the World Series. He pitched 8 innings and gave up just two hits with one walk and 13 strikeouts, further cementing his legacy of a big-time, playoff ace.

#2: August 19, 2009 - Phillies 8 Diamondbacks 1

Not too long after arriving in Philadelphia in a mid-season trade with the Indians, Lee dazzled the D-Backs, and Phils fans, by pitching a complete game, giving up just two hits and one unearned run, with 11 strikeouts and, guess what? No walks! That Game Score of 92 was tied for his all-time highest with...

#1: April 14, 2011 - Phillies 4 Nationals 0

This is officially tied with the previous entry as Lee's best games ever in the history of the world. He pitched a complete game shutout against the Nats, striking out 12, walking one and giving up just three hits, again, for a Game Score of 92.

You'll notice the most famous Lee game of all time, Game 1 of the 2009 World Series, is nowhere to be found on this list. While Lee was brilliant that night, it didn't quite meet the high expectations of the 12 contests listed above, with a Game Score of 83.

That being said, it would be a crime if I didn't include some video of it.

Subscribe to The Felske Files!!!

Click here to subscribe on iTunes. - don't forget to leave a review!

Click here to subscribe on Stitcher.