clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Ruben Tuesdays: Goodbye, Jimmy

Remembering when Ruben Amaro furthered the rebuilding effort by trading a franchise icon

Miami Marlins v Philadelphia Phillies
When it was clear the Phillies were rebuilding, Jimmy Rollins was sent away
Photo by Mitchell Leff/Getty Images

Continuing in my quest to post something every day in December, I’ve revived an old feature from the good old days of 2019. Join me for another edition of Ruben Tuesdays where I spend the second day of the work week discussing a move made by the team’s controversial former general manager.

Goodbye, Jimmy

Despite the team in apparent decline entering the 2014 season, the Phillies - at least publicly - still claimed they thought they could contend for a playoff spot if everything broke right. Things definitely did not break right in 2014, and even the Phillies had to soon admit that they were in need of a rebuild.

One of their most valuable potential trade chips was shortstop Jimmy Rollins. Rollins had declined from his MVP-winning peak but was still a good shortstop who was worth four bWAR in 2014. It seemed like he might fetch them a nice return, but there was one problem: Rollins didn’t want to leave.

Rollins was in pursuit of the Phillies’ all-time hits record, and he made it clear that he didn’t want to leave the team until he had it. And due to his status as a ten and five player, he could block any potential trade.

In June of that season, Rollins accomplished his goal.

Once said record was secured, and the Phillies having begun the rebuilding process in earnest, Rollins became amenable to joining another team.

A trade partner was found in the form of the Los Angeles Dodgers, with the Phillies received pitching prospects Tom Windle and Zach Eflin. Windle never reached the major leagues, but Eflin did, and developed into a solid mid-rotation starter.

Unfortunately, Eflin’s chronically injured knees kept him from reaching his full potential, and he spent a lot of time on the Injured List while with the Phillies. However, he was able to return late in the 2022 season as a reliever and made some key late-inning appearances in the Phillies’ run to the World Series.

Trading away a franchise icon is never easy, but Amaro pulled it off well, especially since Rollins was able to basically choose his destination thanks to his no-trade clause. Not only did Rollins get to move to a team of his liking, but the Phillies got back a pitcher who helped get them to the World Series.